Your spot to relax
Experience Hoagie Haven
Hoagie Haven is a culinary landmark located along Nassau Street in Princeton, New Jersey, celebrated for its mouthwatering "fat sandwiches." This bustling eatery has become a cherished destination for locals and students, known for its hearty hoagies stuffed with tantalizing fillings and fried delights. Customers rave about the impressive portions and flavors, especially the popular Sanchez sandwich, which combines chicken cutlets, mozzarella sticks, and their signature sauce. With a reputation for quick service and friendly staff, Hoagie Haven is more than just a meal—it's an experience that leaves diners satisfied and eager for more. Don't miss out on this iconic spot!
Flavors to Try
Experience today’s special creations
Story & Atmosphere
Hoagie Haven
Welcome to Hoagie Haven, a beloved culinary landmark situated on Nassau Street in Princeton, New Jersey. This iconic eatery has long been the go-to spot for both students and locals craving hearty and indulgent food offerings. Specializing in the famed "fat sandwich," Hoagie Haven boasts a creative menu featuring hoagie rolls overflowing with a variety of fillings and delightful deep-fried sides.
One of the standout dishes is the Sanchez, a monster hoagie that combines chicken cutlet pieces, mozzarella sticks, fries, and the signature Sanchez sauce. With each bite, you experience a burst of flavor that leaves you yearning for more—even after the first humongous serving. It's impossible not to feel satisfied and full after tackling one of these delicious creations.
The atmosphere at Hoagie Haven may be unpretentious, but the dedication to quality and taste shines through. Customers frequently praise the efficient service, often receiving their orders faster than expected—a true testament to the team’s commitment to customer satisfaction. One reviewer noted that the friendly staff makes every visit a delightful experience, ensuring a smooth ordering process even during peak hours.
Despite the sometimes crowded conditions, the allure of the menu keeps loyal patrons returning time and time again—some have even been visiting since 2012. Each visit brings the excitement of discovering new flavors alongside the classic favorites that keep them coming back. However, it’s worth noting that not every combination hits the mark; some diners recommend skipping the mac and cheese as a sandwich add-on, keeping it simple yet flavorful.
If you're in the Princeton area, Hoagie Haven is an essential stop. It's hard to find a more satisfying blend of taste and quantity in a casual dining setting. Whether you’re grabbing a quick meal on the go or planning a late-night indulgence, you’ll find yourself enchanted by the creative sandwiches and the vibrant atmosphere. Don’t just take our word for it—plan your visit and experience the magic of Hoagie Haven for yourself!
For more information, feel free to reach out at +1 609-921-7723.
Shared Experiences
Guestbook
“ The workers are very receptive and respectful. No long wait. Usually they tell you the order will be ready in 15 minutes but mostly comes out earlier than expected. Their souvlakis are the best! ”
“ Hoagie Haven: A Review of Princeton's Legendary Institution Located right on Nassau Street in Princeton, New Jersey, Hoagie Haven is the undisputed champion of the "fat sandwich"—a culinary genre featuring hoagie rolls aggressively stuffed with classic fillings and deep-fried sides. This bustling, unpretentious, and often late-night institution is a rite of passage for students and locals alike, famous for colossal, indulgent creations like the Sanchez (chicken cutlet, mozzarella sticks, fries, and their proprietary Sanchez Sauce) and the Phat Lady (cheesesteak, mozzarella sticks, and fries). Built on fresh bread sourced from the Italian People's Bakery, Hoagie Haven delivers massive portions, tremendous value, and comforting, messy flavors. While traditional cheesesteaks and cold hoagies are available, the true "Haven" experience is embracing the decadence of their unique specialty sandwiches. Just remember to bring your appetite, and be aware that they have historically been cash-preferred. Final Verdict Rating: 5/5 Must-Try: The Sanchez or The Phat Lady ”
“ This place definitely met the high expectations I went in with. I got their most popular whole hoagie (the Sanchez) for a total of $18 with tax. It came with mozzarella sticks, fries, chicken cutlet pieces, and their "Sanchez" sauce. It was humongous and was extremely filling and delicious. Every bite was so good! My friend got their cheesesteak and it was also amazing. I am definitely coming back to this Nassau Street staple. ”
“ Discovered this place simply just walking the Ave. when i tell you the food here is amazing. I can’t believe i never knew about it. My only suggestion is to not try anything with the Mac n cheese. It did not taste good. My sandwich was perfect without it. ”
“ I have been going here since 2012 and it is always a staple when I’m in the area. Quick and easy. Delicious and simple. You have to stop by if you want a legit Phat Sandwich! ”